Criticism of A Historical Commentary on Polybius Letter from W M Edwards ["Bergsteiger"] regarding De Beer's criticism of F W Walbank's Historical Commentary on Polybius (Oxford; 1957), and Walbank's review of Alps and Elephants, enclosing his own comments on De Beer's notes. Accompanying the letter are a typescript copy of De Beer's notes, and a carbon copy of De Beer's outgoing letter. Jan 1957